Linguistic Privilege
May. 24th, 2011 10:50 pmI saw a video of myself being interviewed.
I come across as articulate, informed, and boyish.
Being articulate is useful and being informed is desirable. But the two together explain some hostile reactions in conversation. People hear an educated voice and know that I could, if I wanted to, walk all over their opinions, privately or publicly, with the force of learnedness. And sometimes I do that. I've like to think that I limit this only to when others are saying ignorant hurtful things, and then I've tried to be considerate, but it's hard to say "actually, you're wrong, you're making bad things happen, and here's why."
Articulate and informed yield power and privilege. A lot of class privilege. And the privilege, just or not, of having a reputation for heuristic epistemological authourity - of being someone who really does know what the fuck she's talking about, with testable, verifiable, opinions. But the two are entangled.
I could use this privilege justly, or I could use it at whim. willy-nilly, even on topics where I am wholly ignorant. And it would take a keen mind to tell the difference. When I speak, I hold this over people.
No wonder some people feel defensive.
I come across as articulate, informed, and boyish.
Being articulate is useful and being informed is desirable. But the two together explain some hostile reactions in conversation. People hear an educated voice and know that I could, if I wanted to, walk all over their opinions, privately or publicly, with the force of learnedness. And sometimes I do that. I've like to think that I limit this only to when others are saying ignorant hurtful things, and then I've tried to be considerate, but it's hard to say "actually, you're wrong, you're making bad things happen, and here's why."
Articulate and informed yield power and privilege. A lot of class privilege. And the privilege, just or not, of having a reputation for heuristic epistemological authourity - of being someone who really does know what the fuck she's talking about, with testable, verifiable, opinions. But the two are entangled.
I could use this privilege justly, or I could use it at whim. willy-nilly, even on topics where I am wholly ignorant. And it would take a keen mind to tell the difference. When I speak, I hold this over people.
No wonder some people feel defensive.